Nutrition

Nutritionists Should Consider U.S. Soybean Meal’s Mineral Content when Differentiating between Origins

Although the available data for the mineral content of soybean meal are scarce and often contradictory, soy is considered to be a rich source of minerals and contributes to overall nutritional composition of animal feed. This is particularly true in the case of corn soy diets used for broilers, where the key minerals of the soybean meal contribute an overage of 11% for calcium, 12.5% for available phosphorus, and over 80 for potassium to the total feed supply.

U.S. soybean meal has a different mineral content profile compared to other origins

Nutritionists are asked to keep it all in balance: performances, health, and welfare of the animal and, at the same time, maintaining production efficiency and creating the highest quality end product possible. The highly regulated poultry farming industry and evolving environmental regulations are the key drivers influencing nutritionists to take a close look at the role of minerals playing roles in building metabolic balance, efficiency and achieving high performances in animal farming. A good example in this regard is the phosphorus content of soy, which is the most economically and environmentally important mineral simply because of the increased cost of inorganic phosphates, the widespread use of the enzyme phytase, and concerns about its environmental impact all over the world.

A 2016 study conducted at the University of Madrid, Spain compared the mineral content of soybeans from the three key soy producing countries, the United States, Argentina, and Brazil, demonstrating that the origin of the soybeans affected in different ways the ash and mineral concentration of the soybean meal, with the most striking differences detected for phosphorus, calcium, potassium, and iron.

Phosphorus content was higher for the U.S. and Argentinian meals than for the Brazilian meals, although the differences were of little practical interest. Calcium content was higher and more variable for U.S. meals than for the South American meals. Moreover, calcium concentration was higher than expected based on the average calcium content of the beans reported by research leading organizations.

Meanwhile, the potassium content was higher in the Argentinian than in the Brazilian soybean meals with that of the U.S. meals being intermediate. The variability in content reported for most minerals were perhaps due to differences in soil characteristics, fertilization rate used, and in their availability to be absorbed by the plant. In this regard, the soils in the main soybean planting areas of Brazil are very rich in aluminum (Al) and iron (Fe) and poor in phosphorus. And the availability of these minerals is affected by the pH of the soil. At low pH, the phosphate ions react with Al to form less soluble compounds. However, low soil pH increases Fe and Al absorption.  Consequently, the Brazilian soybeans that are mostly produced in very acidic soils, proved to have less phosphorus and more aluminum and iron contents than the U.S. and Argentine soybean meals. In addition, total ash and some minerals, such as calcium and iron, might appear in the soybean meal as a result of contamination from the soil or the crushing plant.

In conclusion, the mineral content depends on the origin of the soybean meal, with Brazilian origin soybean meals having more iron but less calcium and phosphorus compared to the meals from other origins. Consequently, nutritionists have to consider mineral content in order to properly differentiate between countries of origin when preparing matrices for evaluating the nutritive value of commercial soybean meals and properly select the feed additives to enhance corn soy diets.

Proper harvesting and storage practices in the U.S. allows no contamination with earth, mud, or sand
Iani Chihaia
Iani Chihaia

Animal Nutrition Consultant

USSEC - South East Europe and Greece

Iani CHIHAIA is an Eastern European based consultant in animal nutrition from Bucharest, Romania concentrating on promoting the efficient and safe use of ingredients, current nutrition and formulation concepts in animal nutrition and technology transfer in the area of soy processing for animal feeding.